Getting Punchy
I read some articles earlier in the summer about punch making a comeback in the cocktail world. I was generally discouraged by many of the suggested recipes because I don’t like my drinks that sweet. Besides, I’m not typically making drinks for enough people to justify a punchbowl.
Luckily, all that changed this weekend.
Fully understanding this tale requires a very short trip in the way-back machine to last June. I was down at Buckeye Farm (a stunning country house in Rappahannock County, VA, recently featured on Apartment Therapy and owned by some lovely people to whom Tessa-boy is lucky enough to be related by marriage) celebrating the end of the CFA Level I exam. We’d been making various cocktails throughout the long weekend when I entered into a conversation with my hostess about how she could use as many of the fresh and beautiful herbs she had grown as possible. We decided we should create simple syrups and infused liquors. I set about harvesting lavender, rosemary, and dill before leaving the next day.

Herbs and flowers flourishing on Buckeye Farm
The lavender and rosemary were mostly boiled, strained, and then re-boiled with sugar added in to create syrups. I took some jars of these syrups with me and left some at the Farm. I also took three Ball jars and filled them thus:
1) lavender and gin
2) rosemary and gin
3) dill and vodka
When I returned to the Farm this weekend, the three jars (along with some remaining lavender syrup) were waiting patiently. The lavender was darkest, a rich caramel color. The rosemary was the most aromatic, with a light yellowish-green hue. The dill was the lightest of all.
All three were amazing for martinis or simple concoctions with a liqueur/syrup added in – the dill made a spectacular vodka-tonic.
But the real value of the whole enterprise was the Sunday night barbecue with about 20 people. When helping prepare for the event, people were clear that we should use these locally (from the garden we would be sitting in) flavored drinks to enhance the milieu. I realized that trying to introduce 20 people to unfamiliar drinks could be awkward and take lots of time. Plus, this is the country: people have to drive home (on dark winding roads, no less).
PUNCH
The elegant solution happened to be a trendy one. I could make punches that would use the local ingredients, match the rustic/historic feel of the area, refresh the party, and prevent my bed being taken by guests too sodden to drive. By all accounts the plan worked. Here’s what I made:
Buckeye Farm Gin Punch
0.5 cups lavender gin
1 cup gin
0.5 cup lavender syrup
0.25 cups chamomile grappa
1.5 cups French lemonade
a little dry vermouth
a splash of St. Germain Elderflower Liqueur
0.5 cups powdered sugar
2 lemons
peach bitters
Tweak it to taste in a pitcher, then double the amount of liquid with sparkling water. Pour into a punch bowl with a single block of ice that has fruit pieces frozen into it.
Rose Sparkler
1 bottle sparkling rose
0.5 cup Cointreau
0.5 cup St. Germain Elderflower Liqueur
1.5 cup orangeade
orange bitters
Tweak it to taste in a pitcher, then double the amount of liquid with sparkling water. Pour into a punch bowl with a single block of ice that has fruit pieces frozen into it.
I think the Halloween challenge will involve multiple creations – I like the focus the Halloween challenge will provide.
While I’m not sure I like adding light rum to cider, I do like the cider challenge for a Fall/Thanksgiving beverage. Nothing like spiked apple juice to ruin a perfectly good turkey…
About that Halloween punch — how about something with spice, including the ginger liqueur? Since rum is the standby with cider, could Sherry’s challenge be the chance for somebody to finally coming up with a cider drink with depth and subtlety?
Tess-Boy — We used the dill vodka for a bloody mary when I was at the farm and it ROCKED ! I love the new site and will check back often. I’m actually searching for a new cocktail recipe for Halloween. We have a ragin party each halloween — our block is SERIOUS about this holiday and every one outdoes each other with the decor. We are in need of a signature cocktail for our 40 guests. We still have 3 gallons (!) of light rum left over from mojitios that we served at our wedding party in the barn out back, and want to convert that into a singature (orange, for the appropriate color) beverage for our guests. Thoughts ?
You are my new hero–redfining the way we drink.
I made salad dressing last night with some of the rosemary syrup also leftover from that original syrup-making project – wonderful!! The herb/sweet taste + mustard + olive&vinegar is impossible to go wrong with
So THAT’s what I was drinking and that’s why I had SUCH a good time.
Everybody loved both punches that evening, and at Buckeye Farm we’re inspired to pursue more adventures with herbal syrups. The exploration began in 2008 when nephew Bruce whipped up a batch of lavender/lemon gelato. He left behind extra lavender syrup, and we started exploring options. Early on (although we are mainly wine fans) our favorite mixologist Tessa paid a visit and taught us that a lovely way to start an evening is with a small but intensely flavorful cocktail. His creativity illustrated that it doesn’t take a lot of alcohol to deliver a complex taste sensation. We loved his use of herbs to add additional notes to traditional and innovative cocktails. Then we added lavender syrup to a series of salad dressings started with basics like olive oil, lemon and mustard. Proportions and herbal blends varied according to the lettuces and other treats we found in the garden. A hint of sweetness often seemed right during our long season of adding fat, tart blackberries to summer greens.